Distorted Magazine Cover © Sergey Zarva
What is art? This is an essential question, especially for anyone interested in individual creative expression and the way it connects and contributes to shaping a generalized cultural identity on a mass, wide-spread scale. A New York Times 'Weekend Arts' section in July provides intriguing insight into this potentially daunting question. Even without the thought-provoking commentary of the contributing writers in this section, and the opinions of the artists that they discuss and quote, we have the motley potpourri of subjects themselves, a shot-gun spray of articles falling from one extreme to the other and spread so far apart they would seem to undermine the (ever-evolving) investigation into the nature of art from the get-go.
There is an article on an exhibition of pieces "from, and about, Russia and former soviet bloc countries of Eastern Europe"; another focuses on a biography of David Bowie; a third describes a gallery in the Hamptons where a handful of fighter jet nose cones have been transformed by a group of artists. We have a traditional review of a modernist painter side-by-side with a rocking exposé on the recent proliferation of all-female thrash-metal tribute bands. Despite the apparent incongruousness among these landmarks of the world of art today, a closer examination of thoughts, motives, and contexts of the individuals involved begins to dissolve the disparities (and to drive at the heart of our initial question).
In his article on "Ostalgia", the exhibition centered on Russia and the former Soviet bloc, Holland Cotter describes the pieces as "a response either to the stresses of living under Soviet-style socialism or to the stresses of living without it after the Soviet Union dissolved." That cultural repression in communist Russia would actually foster a boom in certain modes of cultural expression is a not altogether surprising paradox. More interestingly is that post-communism, free-market capitalism could similarly create an environment of suppression perhaps even more stifling to individual expression and art in general. Cotter explains that for some, the new era of freedom "undermined the purpose and value of art." In other words, "for some artists, repression...established art's primary value as moral, not monetary; instrumental, not formal".
Cotter's article adds solid foundational concepts for forming an answer to the question of what is art. We can say art is an act of creation in response to a crisis, either 'political, personal, or both', as Cotter says. We might also add that this response, this creation, is purposeful, directional, even; that it serves to address or cope with the crisis. On the same page as Cotter's piece on "Ostalgia" is Ken Johnson's review of the "eerie, erotically menacing" leather and wood head sculptures by Nancy Grossman. Here we find the idea of art as creation in response to crisis upheld. Johnson discusses the creation of the heads as a reaction to drastic shifts in social consciousness with regards to women and sexuality in the '60s. Paralleling Cotter's sentiments, Johnson also points out the potential for personal crisis for Grossman (her work a "flirtation with a powerful but otherwise buried part of herself") as another source of inspiration for her pieces.
While the idea of art as creation in response to crisis (political and personal) is solidly supported, it might still fall short in doing justice to the full gamut of modes of expression that we (and the 'Weekend Arts' section) deem to be art. What of creative expressions that are not derived from crisis, but are also not solely executed with monetary or formal value in mind? On the front page of the Weekend Arts section, Roberta Smith's review of the modernist Lyonel Feininger mentions that the artist had "drawn incessantly since childhood", but fails to point to an overt crisis to which his art was a direct response. Instead, the artist himself is quoted describing his conviction that painting is "a path to the intangibility of the divine". Unless Feininger's art-inspiring crisis was a personal struggle with mysticism, religion, and the placing of human-kind in a larger context (the familiar 'is their a god?' struggle), then his work and philosophy point to a deepening of our understanding of what is art.
Perhaps it is not surprising that it is with music that we begin to see our understanding of art begin to coalesce into a single, unified picture. Music has long been considered to be an approach to the divine - the word itself is derived from a Greek word meaning 'art of the Muses', those goddesses of artistic creation. In the case of this issue of the Weekend Arts section, dated Friday, July 23, 2011, it seems paradoxically sweet that the music under the magnifying glass, that which will tie this discussion of art together, is the wailing riffs and howling vocals of bands the likes of Misstallica, Lez Zeppelin, and the Iron Maidens. While these all-female hard-rock and heavy-metal tribute bands offer no shortage of hair swinging, head banging theatrics in paying homage to the original groups (i.e. Metallica, Led Zeppelin, Iron Maiden), they aren't to be taken lightly. According to Amanda Petrusich, the author of this Weekend Arts piece, "In a 2005 article in Spin, Chuck Klosterman suggested that Lez Zeppelin might be 'the most powerful all-female band in rock history'". So it shouldn't be surprising that Steph Paynes is quoted in this article as describing the music and art she is a part of in the following way: "'Sometimes you feel like his [Jimmy Page's] playing is exploding and it's going to completely combust. But it doesn't somehow, it just takes you totally to the edge. And that, to me, is a very exciting place to be - in life and art.'"
At the end of the weekend (and of the Weekend Arts section) we see art as expression that has the capacity to move an individual through a crisis (thus creating a potential stage for moral and political commentary), and, in the end, to even approach a "reality larger than itself" (as Cotter says of "Ostalgia"), an understanding or context beyond the individual. Perhaps those creations serving as responses to crises and those that totally take one to the edge of complete personal reality combustion are all part of the same path, Feininger's "path to the intangibility of the divine".
Lyonel Feininger in his New York City studio, taken by his son Andreas Feininger, 1951, Time Life Pictures


No comments:
Post a Comment